Thank you to everyone who submitted answers to the first ever Ask Jbrary. Boy did you all deliver! I have the best blog community, hands down. I got so many responses in fact (almost 100!) that I am not able to feature them all. I have done my best to summarize, pull out quotes I think are particularly well said, and add in my own thoughts. Needless to say, this post is a BEAST.
I will henceforth refer to you collectively as “the blog community” and to individuals as “blog members.”
Ask Jbrary
Dear Jbrary,
I am saddened to see so many caregivers glued to their cellphones and missing out on all these rich “serve and return” opportunities. What can I say or do at storytime to help caregivers engage with their young children?
The Blog Community Answers
What I like about this question is that it seeks to engage caregivers, not punish them. Many strategies were shared to help create an interactive storytime with clear expectations for the group.
Reserving Judgment
The first thing I recommend is to reflect on your own feelings. It’s natural to feel frustrated when caregivers are doing something you don’t want them to do, but we don’t want to get stuck in those feelings. The blog community picked up on the need to reserve judgment and to check assumptions. One blog member said, “One of the programs I was in at ALA this year talked about storytime sometimes being the only time a primary caregiver can relax/decompress. It really made me think about this issue in a different light.” I think the following quote sums it up perfectly:
We do not know what’s going on in caregivers’ lives.
Many blog members reiterated this point:
- Everyone at story time is part of an important community. Staff doesn’t know what is going in adults’ lives. Caregivers may need to communicate with someone or read something during story time.
- I always try to remember that full time caregivers don’t get breaks, especially if their kids aren’t napping. I remember when I was home on maternity leave, I would just want 10 minutes!
- I think many adults taking care of children all day need that small bit of time when they can disengage, at a place where their kids will be safe. They need to be present all day, and the library gives them the best place to take a breath for themselves. I don’t like it, but I understand and respect that. And so, as long as the kids are safe and not disruptive, the adults are not too loud or totally checked out, I just carry on with story time, and hope that the kids and the adults will carry home some tiny part of story time for themselves, and each other.
I especially like how this blog member framed it as an issue that they work on together with the caregiver. This stops it from being an us vs. them situation and re-centers our goal of coming together as a community.
We work to be understanding that sometimes adults feel a need to respond to a text or take a picture. When there is an adult with a child who brings a lap top or is engrossed on their phone to the extent they are not paying attention to their child we will address it one-to-one. We remind them that it is a caregiver-child program. If there is something urgent/critical maybe we can work out some time at the end so they can quickly take care of that while we clean up and interact with their child. Guidelines with some understanding and support seem to have worked for us.
Instead of judgment, tap into your empathy.
I come at this with empathy. Encourage parents to model behavior. Include interactive songs, rhymes, play. But, if a parent chooses to opt out of participation at that point, give them that space. Maybe that is what they need in that moment. And next time maybe they will participate. The more they get to know, if you talk to them before and after programs the more buy-in they will have. I would hate for a parent to feel unwelcome/judged if this isn’t approached with empathy because as a parent, we feel like we are judged ALL the time.
Set Expectations Early
An overwhelming number of blog members spoke to the importance of setting group expectations at the start of storytime in order to guide caregivers in how to participate. When we are friendly and direct about how to participate and why, we set caregivers up for success. Here are some examples of how blog members communicate expectations:
- We front load the storytime expectations with those in attendance. We announce the following at the beginning of the program: Grownups please put away your phones and tune in with the kiddos during this time. Please save adult conversations until after storytime. Grownups please sing the songs and say the words to the rhymes with us. This let’s your little one know that storytime is a safe place to be and they will get more out of the program if they are an active participant. (Then we display the words in a PowerPoint so they are able to actually do it.)
- At the beginning of Storytime, as part of housekeeping comments, I always say something like: “If your little one is too young to be able to follow some of the actions on their own, then adults, you can help them move their bodies to participate, or modify some of the actions to suit their abilities. If your little one is a bit older, I would still like to ask the adults to join me in all of the actions and songs as much as possible—you can be a role model for paying attention and participating, and the little ones will learn by watching you even more than by watching me!”
- I open every storytime with a little spiel thanking caregivers for taking time out of their busy days to prioritize their child’s early literacy development, and say something like “To make storytime as fun and enriching as possible, I ask that all of the grownups in the room do their best to participate and stay engaged in everything we do together today, because the more engaged the adults in the room are, the more the little ones will get out of it. And to that end, let’s all find our feet and get ready to wake them up!” I also have a slideshow to accompany each storytime, so the words to the songs and rhymes we do together are all displayed behind me.
- In a previous position of mine, our program staff had posters with ‘Storytime Guidelines’ that we would review before most storytimes, or at least highlight one ‘guideline’ each week. They were really just reminders like ‘be present,’ ‘you’re your child’s favorite person,’ and ‘it’s okay to take breaks.’ It didn’t fix everything, but it created a precedent and some accountability for parents to focus on the moment at hand and not get lost in technology.
Some blog members shared example wording that specifically speaks to the why we are asking caregivers to participate.
- “Participation is important – remember that you are your child’s first and most important teacher – they will want to join if they see you joining in and having fun”
- “Grownups, the more you can participate, the more comfortable your child feels – and the more comfortable *I* feel! [this usually gets a laugh] I love to hear your voices join mine. In fact, I think of myself as not the center of storytime, but just a helper! My role is to help you and your little one have some special time bonding and having fun today.”
- “We ask that everyone be present with us during storytimes. Caregivers, you are your child’s role model. The more you participate and be present during storytime, the more your child will do the same and everyone will have fun.”
- “We always encourage you to play an active role in storytime. The more you participate, the more your little one learns along with you.”
Lastly, I had to share this acronym from a blog member because who doesn’t love an acronym!
I start out every storytime with a small aside about guidelines for grownups. I say during storytime we’re focusing on our KIDS:
K: Keep your child near. (We do expect some wandering, so no need to hold your child firmly in your lap.)
I: Intervene if your child distracts others. (We keep our child near so that we can intervene if they distract or get in another’s personal space.)
D: Do the activities with your child. (For our more bashful kids, it’s important to see you doing the motions too. The more you participate, the more likely they are to participate)
S: Save conversations for after storytime. (We love helping you build community and be a part of your community. But we are here for our kids so let’s wait until after to talk with each other.)
This little acronym has really helped keep our grownups engaged with their kids!
Choose Content Wisely
The suggestions in this post focus on the things you can control, and one of the biggest things you can control in storytime is the content. When we choose interactive books, songs, and activities, caregivers are more likely to put down their devices and engage with their children. Here are some specific examples from blog members:
- I start story time with a song that encourages adults to pick up their kids and cuddle with them. I add a movement in the middle that adults and children could enjoy together. I make available all the books, songs and fingerplays we did together at that story time on a flyer, so that they could also enjoy them at home.
- I have certain activities that I require adult help (like parachute time or certain movement songs that need a partner) and I think this helps remind caretakers that their participation is wanted.
- We start our story time with fifteen minutes of group play with blocks, train tracks, or something messy. This provides the caregivers with breathing time. Then when the group picks up and comes to the carpet for stories, I or a child volunteer pass out shaker eggs TO ALL. By including the caregivers in the first activity on the carpet (with something in their hands other than a phone) it is more likely that they participate in the entire story time routine with their child.
One blog member gave an excellent description about how they choose activities that engage all ages:
I think part of this also comes down to finding that bit of magic where your storytime content and delivery style is engaging for all ages. Throw in the odd little joke or tidbit for the adults (“The babies on the bus go ‘wah, wah, wah’ all through the town — we’ve all been there, right? So parents, what are we going to say to those babies?”). Celebrate your mistakes to show them its ok if they don’t remember the words to a song (“Oops, I got myself a bit mixed up with those verses, but we’ll sing the correct one now!”). I find that stories with a repeating line (like Brown Bear, Brown Bear, What Do You See?) also work really well because the parents pick it up really quickly when I tell them to repeat the line back, and by the end of the story all the older kids are doing it too. This gives me a great place to show them those opening comments in action, because their kids are learning by watching and listening to them.
Here are a few more tips from me:
- Choose familiar songs and rhymes. If you are introducing too many new things in storytime caregivers will check out. Try featuring more “tried and true” storytime songs like Zoom, Zoom, Zoom, Old MacDonald, and Wheels on the Bus. You can get creative with the animals on the farm (octopus, anyone?) and the actions on the bus (the people on the bus tap in and out)
- Choose songs and rhymes that ask caregivers to do something with their little one. For example, Here’s a Cup asks caregivers to make cups with their hands and share some tea with their little one. If you sing a lullaby you can call it a “snuggle song” and encourage kids to find a lap for some snuggles as you sing. Here is a Beehive ends in a tickle. Peek-a-Boo has a built in game.
- Ask the families what songs they love or what songs they sing at home. Include their suggestions. Be open to learning a song in a different language that your audience speaks.
Make Singing Along Accessible
Even if you’ve chosen the best songs and rhymes, you can go a step further by making singing along more accessible. Here are some strategies from the blog community which I think are especially helpful for ESL families:
- I use Canva presentation to post the words to my songs, rhymes, and anything to keep the caregivers involved.
- I print out the lyrics to everything I’m going to sing, including opening and closing songs, and mention that I need anybody who can read to sing along. Knowing that they are needed, and have ways to participate, makes for a much richer experience for all of us.
Verbal encouragement can go a long way too!
- I am always asking parents to sing with me. I sort of make a joke of it that I don’t have the greatest voice in the world. I say “help me out grownups!” or “Everybody!”
- I try to keep it light by saying things like “Don’t make me read/sing alone” or ” the children/babies want to hear you singing, not me!”
- On a general scale, interacting with caregivers has really improved my results – a bit of gratitude goes a long way for tired parents who are already going out of their way to do something good for their baby. I like to include things like “beautiful singing, grown-ups! No matter what you think of your own voice, you are a rockstar to your little one.” Or, after a lifting song, “And good job to grown-ups for being the best elevators/rocket ships/ponies!”
Looping back to showing empathy, I love how one blog member summarized their experience:
I think it’s easy to forget that caregivers are going above and beyond just for showing up, and it’s nice to remind them that we appreciate them just as much as they appreciate us. It might not combat the phone issue directly, but it’s one of those many many little things that can make them feel more inclined to participate.
Rules Around Photography
Lastly, some blog members have official no photo/video policies at their libraries that allow them to be more direct in asking for devices to be put away. We have this policy at my library for programs and I usually say something like, “Grown-ups, we ask that you tuck away your devices during storytime and refrain from taking photos to ensure everyone’s privacy. When the program is over and people are able to move about freely, feel free to snap a picture or video.” Even without a policy, blog members shared sample wording you can use to discourage phone use.
I ask that they refrain from taking pictures and videos during class as it can be a safety risk for others. (Having worked in schools, I am aware of families that need to keep their child’s location private for various reasons)
I have a remark about photos: “We ask that you please do not take any photos of videos during the program. For 2 reasons: 1) It’s distracting for me and other people attending the program, and most importantly, 2) for privacy reasons, because other people might not be ok with their kids in our pictures. I know we all want to record every single moment of our baby/child, I’ve done that too, and you’re welcome to take pictures of your kids in the library after the program, but please make sure you’re not capturing other people in your frame.”
Reading all of these wonderful suggestions, I hope you feel much more confident about how to engage caregivers on devices. Please feel free to add any additional thoughts in the comments!
I love these tips! It was so fun reading through everyone’s comments last week. One quick note about photography: for librarians in the United States, it’s important to double check your state’s public photography laws carefully before making any policies about picture taking in storytime. In my state, Massachusetts, the library is considered a public space and therefore all recording is considered legal. Unfortunately, there’s been a rash of people who go into libraries and other legally designated public spaces, like town halls or police stations, and record the librarians or other patrons to post to their YouTube channels (they generally also accuse the people they’re recording of breaking the law, or other inflammatory things, to get a reaction). In these situations, asking people to stop recording, even for safety reasons (and yes, even of children) can create a whole host of legal trouble for the library, and has caused some of the librarians featured in the videos to get harassed online. I can’t recommend looking these videos up, honestly, as they’re pretty sickening, but for reference they’re usually called “first amendment audits.”
I completely agree with the reasons given for not taking pictures in storytime – and highly encourage those able to do so to make policies against it – but just wanted to give a warning that in some places banning photography can get you into murky waters, legally.
Thank you for sharing all of these tips!
hey guys we love you and your videos. me and my girlfriend watch together and we say that you are us bc we are library lesbians. maybe you are not in love but in our hearts you are. is sophie your daughter? you make a beautiful family. are we delusional? maybe. but it gives me hope